Music Genre Classification Revisited: An In-Depth Examination Guided by Music Experts
نویسندگان
چکیده
Despite their many identified shortcomings, music genres are still often used as ground truth and as a proxy for music similarity. In this work we therefore take another in-depth look at genre classification, this time with the help of music experts. In comparison to existing work, we aim at including the viewpoint of different stakeholders to investigate whether musicians and end-user music taxonomies agree on genre ground truth, through a user study among 20 professional and semi-professional music protagonists. We then compare the results of their genre judgments with different commercial taxonomies and with that of computational genre classification experiments, and discuss individual cases in detail. Our findings coincide with existing work and provide further evidence that a simple classification taxonomy is insufficient.
منابع مشابه
شناسایی خودکار سبک موسیقی
Nowadays, automatic analysis of music signals has gained a considerable importance due to the growing amount of music data found on the Web. Music genre classification is one of the interesting research areas in music information retrieval systems. In this paper several techniques were implemented and evaluated for music genre classification including feature extraction, feature selection and m...
متن کاملMultiexpert System for Automatic Music Genre Classification
Automatic classification of music pieces by genre is one of the crucial tasks in music categorization for intelligent navigation. In this work we present a multiExpert genre classification system based on acoustic, musical and timbre features. A novel rhythmic characteristic, 2D beat histogram is used as high-level musical feature. Timbre features are extracted by multiple-f0 detection algorith...
متن کاملAutomatic Genre Classification of Latin Music Using Ensemble of Classifiers
This paper presents a novel approach to the task of automatic music genre classification which is based on ensemble learning. Feature vectors are extracted from three 30-second music segments from the beginning, middle and end of each music piece. Individual classifiers are trained to account for each music segment. During classification, the output provided by each classifier is combined with ...
متن کاملClustering Music Recordings Based on Genres 2061 2 . Problem Formulation
Existing systems for automatic genre classification follows a supervised framework that extracts genre-specific information from manually-labeled music data and then identifies unknown music data. However, such systems may not be suitable for personal music management, because manually labeling music based on individually-defined genres can be labor intensive and subject to inconsistence from t...
متن کاملMusic Genre Classification Using Text Categorization Method
Automatic music genre classification is one of the most challenging problems in music information retrieval and management of digital music database. In this paper, we propose a new method to classify music genres using text categorization methods. Differing from previous solutions which were mainly based on analysis on acoustic or symbolic audio signal, here we consider music as a text-like se...
متن کامل